Tredyffrin Easttown Historical Society
History Quarterly Digital Archives

Source: April 1962 Volume 12 Number 1, Pages 13–16

Supplee Cemetery at Mount Pleasant

Page 13

Interview with Luke Baghorn and George Noblit, May 21, 1961

"George Noblit was at one time caretaker of the Carr Schoolhouse and Supplee Cemetery. George's uncle passed a hat around going from door to door to collect enough money to put the iron fence which is presently surrounding the Supplee Cemetery. For many years the cemetery was left uncared for and unprotected from the trash of passers-by and the vandalism of the younger generation, and some of the tombstones are gone. There is no official record of the burials in the Supplee Cemetery and there is only one known copy of the tombstones in the graveyard, with none being made for the recent burials. There are three (or more) graves with no stones and there are quite a few stone markers with no identification on them. Some of the unknown dead are men from Philadelphia who had requested burial at Mt. Pleasant. All the people buried in the Supplee Cemetery are white and are of the original settlers of Mt. Pleasant, so that there are a few plots which are yet to be filled. The cemetery is still in use."

Supplee Cemetery

Copied by Charles Barker

Anderson, Alexander. d. 4/12/1914; aged 86 years,
Elizabeth Whiteford wife Alexander. d. 5/30/1887; aged 6

Bowman, Benzette. d. 6/23/1833; aged 5 mos.
Leonard F.d. 4/7/l843; aged 6yrs. 8 mo. 7 days

Carr, Isaac S. b. 7/31/1839. d. 9/14/1899; Private in Capt.
George S. Roberts Co. E. 3rd Regt. Pa. Artillery
Enrolled 10/20/1862; discharged 10/19/1865; (G.A.R. flag)
Hiram C. son James & Martha; d. 2/23/1851; aged 20 yrs.
Jones B. son James & Martha; aged 8 mos.
Angie. dau. James & Martha; aged 2 yrs. 10 mos.
Martha. b. 4/6/1806; d. 7/26/1895; aged 90 yrs.
James d. 8/16/1864; aged 75 yrs.
Addie. d. 11/28/1858
McCleese. Priv. Co. A. 8th Pa. d.8/22/1898;aged 63 yr.
(G.A.R.)
Leonard F. B. 8/3/1833; d. 3/28/1907. Father.
Hannah S. wife Leonard F. 1840-1925.
Isaac C. son Leonard F. & Hannah S. d. 6/19/1862; age 1 yr.
B. Rowland, son Leonard F. Hannah S. d. 3/16/1870; aged 3
Hiram T. son Leonard F. & Hannah S. b. 4/23/l869; d.4/23/1873
Charles, son John & Ann; d. 10/16/1833; aged 5yr. 3mo. 16 days

Carver, Elizabeth. d. 11/16/1837; aged 64 yrs.

Page 14

Cornog, Taresa J. wife Theodore Cornog; d. 2/23/1852; aged 48 years
Theodore; b. 4/28/1810; d. 9/5/1887; age 77 yrs. 4 mo. 5 ds.
Margaret; wife Theodore; b.10/20/1810; d. 8/10/1897.

Crothers, Thalia M. b. 6/5/1863; d. 11/2/1930.

Crimes, James; U.S. Navy, (G. A. R. marker).

Davidson, John P. b. 10/31/1828; d. 4/29/1885
Agnes, wife John P.; d. 3/23/1896; aged 70 yrs.
Jane. b. 10/24/1809;d. 12/28/1890; aged 80 yrs. 3 mo. 4 dys.
Samuel. d. 4/27/1885; aged 54 yrs. (G.A.R. marker) Father
Mary. 1826-1903
James.1830-1903

Davis, J. R. Sgt. Co. I, 51 Pa. Inf. (G.A.R. marker)
Mary A. 1843-1926

Fletcher, Samuel. 1865-1915.

Gardner, Samuel. 1859-1944.
Ella, wife of Samuel, 1866-1945.

Grant, Charles H. 1842-1918
William, 1887-1924.
Elmer, 1864-1929.
Ellen J. 1866-1955

Hardy, J. H. 1815-1897.
Charles, 1870-1882.
Sarah A. b. 8/6/1839; d. 8/1/1917

Henry, Mary, 1822-1905.
William, d. 10/8/1886; aged 71 yrs.

Houlker, Sidney, 1826-1887.
Betty, 1826-1909.

Kilpatrich, Thomas, d. 4/8/1879; aged 65 yrs. (G.A.R. flag)

Leamy, Caroline S. 1837-1914.
Mostella. d. 12/l9/l871. aged 6 yrs.
Baldwin, d. 3/18/1885; aged 6 weeks.
Zachariah, d. 11/21/1875; aged 41 yrs. (G.A.R. marker Pst. 11.)

Miskimmins, Anne B. dau. Andrew & Martha; b. 12/15/1887; d. 3/21/1888
Margaret Henry, b. 12/15/1887; d.7/17/1888.
Martha S. 1865-1897

Morris, Elwood, 1848-1929.
Mary C. his wife 1862-1935

Page 15

Muench, Charles H. 2/21/1877; 3/23/1931.
Walter Field, b. 11/6/1912; d. 11/18/1922.

Murray, George W. b. 8/31/1821; d. 10/13/1886; aged 65 yrs.
Elizabeth S. wife George W; dau. John & Hannah Supplee; born
4/6/1816; died 8/20/1874.
Anne, dau. George W. & Elizabeth Murray; b.4/l9/l854; d. 7/19/18
Mary J. Jan. 1846 - Jan. 1912.

Roberts, Eli. 12/28/1847; d. 2/29/1932.
Mary A. b. 12/22/1851; d. 2/3/1933.
Eli. b. 8/28/1885; d. 9/17/1903. aged 18 yrs.

Simes, John, 1841-
Helena W. his wife, 1853-1917.

Stalker, William. b. 2/12/1857; d. 4/14/1940.
Sarah E. b. 9/1/1866; d. 1/17/1949.

Stilfield, T.; Smith's Co. Act'g Eng'rs Pa. Inf. (G.A.R. marker)
Wm. H. 1859-1910
Alfred. b. 2/6/1864; d. 2/1/1927.

Supplee, Hughes, son Edward & Rebecca; d. 2/13/1837; aged 6 mos.
Charles H. son Edward & Rebecca; d.4/8/1833, aged 7 mos.
Miria A. b. 8/19/1816; d. 9/24/1891
Peter. b. 4/8/1808; d. 12/30/1891.
Mary. d. 10/4/1841; aged 42 yrs. 6 mos. 7 dys.
Hannah, wife John. d. 6/30/1865; aged 96 yrs. 2 mos. 17 dys.
John. d. 11/20/1859; aged 91 yrs. 8 mos. 16 dys.

Tompkins, Mary. dau. Samuel & Emma I.; d. 6/6/1868; aged 1 yr. 9 mo. 4 dys.
Howard O. b. 7/23/1882; d. 11/29/1929.
Samuel H. Co.A 82 Reg't P.V. d. 1/29/1918.(G.A.R.& T.O.T.E marker)
Emma J. 1841-1907
Lillie M. 1855-1870.

Whiteford, Thomas. 1818-1875
Sarah. 1830-1885.
Mary Ella, dau Sarah E. b. 11/27/1890; d. 5/28/1902.
Wm. J. 1857-1939.

Walton, W. Mm. Soldier of 61 to 65. (G.A.R. marker)

Weaver, Ella G. 1887-1945.
Walter T. 1888-19 -

Wolfe, Hunter P. 1866-1944
Anne E. 1866-
John Mathias, b. 10/17/1832; d. 1/15/1901

Page 16

Wolfe, Mary A. b. 6/25/1833; d. 3/6/1915.
Albert S. b. 1/1/1875; d. 5/22/1878.
Benjamin F. b. 4/6/1878; d. 4/8/1879.
Wright, Harry P. son Wilson & Adaline. d. 4/28/1870; aged 11 mos.
J. Wilson, d. 10/30/1871; aged 55 yrs. Father.
Hannah Pyewell, dau. J. Wilson & Adaline; d. 10/29/1871. age 9
Adeline. wife J. Wilson. d. 9/26/1875; aged 48 yrs. Mother.